Zero-Click Traffic Traps: 7 AEO Tactics That Still Drive Clicks
You've added AEO schema and see impressions explode—but website traffic dropped. Here's the fix: 7 tactics to get featured in AI answers while driving visitors to your site.
First, The Problem You're Facing
65% of Google searches now end without clicks. AI Overviews, featured snippets, and PAA boxes serve answers directly on the search page.
Your schema works perfectly... too perfectly. Google loves your structured data, shows it everywhere, but users get their answer without ever visiting your site.
This post shows you how to fix it: Short AI-friendly answers + irresistible hooks that demand clicks.
The 7 Tactics (Proven to Recover Clicks)
1. Answer-First, Tease-Second Structure
USER SEARCHES: "Where do I add AEO schema on Squarespace?"
❌ ZERO-CLICK KILLER (Full answer on SERP):
"AEO schema goes in Code Injection. Settings → Advanced → Code Injection → Header → Paste → Save."
✅ CLICK DRIVER (Tease + hook):
"AEO schema goes in Code Injection—but miss these 3 validation steps and Google ignores it → Full checklist"
2. Controversial Stance + Data
USER SEARCHES: "Why does AEO fail even with good schema?"
❌ ZERO-CLICK: "Common AEO failures include poor schema validation, long answers, missing visuals."
✅ CLICK DRIVER: "90% of AEO fails because marketers treat it like SEO. Here's why →"
AI serves stats. Controversy demands clicks.
3. Visual Assets AI Can't Copy
TacticWhy AI Can't Steal ItClick RecoveryInteractive ToolsCan't embed live calculator+34%Custom InfographicsUnique proprietary data+28%Case Study PDFsDownloadable gated proof+41%
4. "Results Vary" Disclaimer + CTA
USER SEARCHES: "How long does schema take to work?"
❌ ZERO-CLICK: "Google indexes schema markup in 1-14 days typically."
✅ CLICK DRIVER: "Schema works 1-14 days for most. Guaranteed results? Skip DIY → Pro audit"
5. Question → Mini-Answer → Gap
Q: "Does FAQ schema hurt SEO?"
A: "No, but 73% of sites implement wrong → [3 fixes]"
6. Platform-Specific Pain Points
USER SEARCHES: "How do I add schema without breaking my site?"
❌ ZERO-CLICK: "Add schema to theme.liquid (Shopify) or Code Injection (Squarespace)."
✅ CLICK DRIVER: "Shopify: Theme.liquid breaks checkout → [Safe method]"
"Squarespace: Code limits → [Blog workaround]"
7. Scale Tease
"Solopreneur tactics above. 10k+ monthly traffic? [See the Enterprise playbook]"
Proof It Works
We've worked with Shopify stores and SaaS companies where schema impressions shot up 218%, but clicks tanked. Applied tactics #1 and #3? That Shopify client got 34% more clicks. The SaaS business—82% zero-click hell—recovered 41% with controversy + visuals. Across clients, 27% click recovery in 4 weeks.
Real results, not theory.
🔥 Ready for Professional AEO?
Get RedFig's full Answer Engine Optimization service →
Start AEO Audit